Published on November 3rd, 2016 | by Makena Morgan


A Thrilling Review of Escape Bloody Mary

Since the beginning of time, human cultures have assumed reflections are doorways to other worlds, that the person looking back at you from the mirror is living his or her own life, and has their own soul. One of our most longstanding fears is seeing something in that mirror, only to have something look back.

This fear spawned the creation of the legend Bloody Mary, a nefarious ghoul who’ll crawl into our world when you look at a bathroom mirror, turn off the lights, light some candles, and say to your reflection, “Bloody Mary… Bloody Mary… Bloody Mary…”. It’s a frightful idea, one that many have tried but some are hesitant to commit to. Thanks to the developers of Well Told Entertainment, you can practice the ritual of summoning Bloody Mary herself from the hopefully complete safety of a virtual reality horror escape room: Escape Bloody Mary.

You play as a child who’s dared by his friends to commit the ritual: you’ve read the lore, you’ve gathered the candles, you know how to guard against her by keeping the candles lit, and the only question remains is if she appears, how long can you survive?

From the start, it’s unnerving how tall everything is. You can barely reach the sink to light the candles, and the bathroom feels genuinely claustrophobic. When the lights go out it feels like you’re a kid again committing some half-hearted nighttime prank.


When spying the infamous creature crawling through the window, you can only view her directly through the mirror which inserts a sort of paranoia and a need to keep glancing at the reflection no matter how much you don’t want to. The only way you can keep her at bay while solving puzzles is to always relight the candles she constantly blows out while keeping an eye on the mirror to show which direction she comes from (the door, the toilet, the shower) so you can see her coming and stop her. It’s Bloody Mary’s ever encroaching presence that injects urgency and panic while trying to find the next item to solve the next puzzle.

However after a while, initial fear can turn to tedium as her movements start to become predictable and you can generally stop her before she even appears. However this delusion of control can actually serve to crowd judgment and prevent you from solving puzzles that have logical answers. This may make it less enjoyable depending on how well you can work best under pressure.

Near the end you can get a general grasp on “Scary Mary” and eventually figure out the puzzles. However it’s when you feels safe near the end that Bloody Mary gives it her A-game. In one last ditch effort to claim you she takes a 180 and messed with her own rules, which doesn’t feel out of place nor out of character unlike most horror games. All at once the terror is reawakened and results in one last desperate search for the last clue to escape Bloody Mary before she drags you away.

This is where the game’s effectiveness as a laxative might also be a partial hindrance. In a state of panic the player can fail to realize the game literally showing them that they have to let certain things happen in order to progress. However this can be more of a nitpick than anything and doesn’t make the game unwinnable.

Overall if you want a genuine horror experience this season devoid of jump scares, Escape Bloody Mary is the perfect game for you. While the gameplay can be rather simplistic at times, Escape Bloody Mary keeps a constant atmosphere of terror that’ll have you hesitating to look in your mirror tonight. Till next time, Bloody Mary…Bloody Mary…Bloody Mary…

For more info on Escape Bloody Mary, check out Well Told Entertainment’s YouTube Channel and website!

About the Author

Makena Morgan is a Creative Writing major at Chapman University. He enjoys writing fiction stories involving fantasy, scifi, and horror as well marathoning You Tubers Markiplier and Jacksepticeye. He has an obsession with manga, animated movies, and anything Japanese. Don't worry, he is easily distracted by bad puns, pop culture reference, and grape flavored everything.

  • Kara Ashbeck

    My own reflection scares me enough 🙁

    It sounds like you had oodles of fun playing the game! I especially like the inclusion of your video playthrough; it makes the review really personal and your voice here shines like it did on your IndieCade article. With that said, it felt so personal that I still felt like this was more of a reflection versus a critical review. I appreciate that you critiqued the game’s “tedium” and described the game vividly, but I think you had some opportunity to dig deeper and analyze the game. Of course, this you played this in IndieCade, I imagine it would be hard to do so! So my critiques are more for the future when or if you decide to give a more traditional review.

    I still think you have a knack for reflections and should specialize! I love hearing your voice and as a review with a more personal and reflective spin, this article succeeds. Great job! I hope you get to experience more VR in the future.

    • Makena Morgan

      Thank you. Before, my first drafts was even more personal so I had to revamp a lot of the framework but I can see some of it still bled through. It’s hard to draw from personal experience and try to make in neutral. That being said the game really was excellent and drew out a lot of good horror tropes. Even though I usually wouldn’t touch horror with a ten foot flamethrower, I appreciated it for what it brought to the table and I did have fun because of the whole immersive VR experience. I am starting to get a general feel for my writing and reflections are getting easier despite the fact originally I thought they were going to be the hardest with my inexperience playing video games. Thank you for the reflection, and see you next time!

  • Evan Maier-Zucchino

    I liked how in depth you were able to get with this. Right when I started thinking to myself, “this gameplay loop sounds like it could get tedious” you started talking about that exact point. This is something I’ve only vaguely thought about until now, but should we review VR experiences the same way we review other games? Do the same structures and details of emphasis work? This sounds like the kind of thing you can only play once and then, when you know all the puzzles, it would be too easy to beat. I would’ve liked to know if the puzzles get randomized from playthrough to playthrough. Overall though you set up an engaging atmosphere and really dived into an analysis of your experience.

  • Josh Smith

    Seems like a pretty unnerving horror experience in VR. That sucks that the difficulty ramping is flawed, otherwise I feel like this would be consistently frightening experience. VR definitely holds much potential for horror games, but I’ve heard that developers need to consider the ethics of the experiences they create with it. Make a game too scary in VR, and you could really cause damage to someone mentally and/or physically. I for one can’t wait to try out new VR horror like Escape Bloody Mary, as I personally love having my limits pushed. Thanks for the review, I wouldn’t have known about this game otherwise! Analysis was spot on as well, particularly with your critique of the late game issues.

  • Pingback: Escape Bloody Mary: Interview with developer Matthew Rebong | Top Shelf Gaming()

  • Pingback: Resident Evil 7 - Game of the Month | Top Shelf Gaming()

Back to Top ↑